咁玩法會唔會危險左些少呢?

原帖由 hkbw 於 2007-2-14 00:33 發表


香港既例, 等小弟遲d再詳細CHECK一CHECK看一看...

但如果香港係呢方面的規例依然係根據英國的法例為主體的話(小弟都冇聽聞過近年有修例),
那單手駕車就未必犯法了.

小弟係英國學車時, 有一堂, 小弟 ...

Actually, I was told by my uncle (and he is a cop) that both hands should remain on the wheel the whole time
while the wehicle is in motion.
If you are driving a manual transmission, you are allowed to use one hand for shifting
but that hand should be free from the wheel only when shifting is needed
and as soon as you are done with the shifting process, both hands should be on the wheel
and they should be placed at "10o'clock" and "2 o'clock" position on the wheel

Thats the rule (law); nobody enforces it doesnt mean its not there, same way for the footware rules while driving.

原帖由 dicksonboy 於 2007-2-16 02:50 發表


Actually, I was told by my uncle (and he is a cop) that both hands should remain on the wheel the whole time
while the wehicle is in motion.
If you are driving a manual transmission, you ar ...

而家上面有板友就quote左香港法例出來, 你能否quote相關法例出來參考?

原帖由 hkbw 於 2007-2-16 05:32 發表


而家上面有板友就quote左香港法例出來, 你能否quote相關法例出來參考?

I quoted worlds from a HK police who had been working with the traffic law for years
If that wasn't good enough, then please pardon me


Let me tell you something about instrutors:
The transit next door (i am currently working for a transit and we share our dispatch office with another transit)
their drivers always turn illegally, and they were all taught that way by their instrutors:  
we drive on the right side, whenever the bus or a long vehicle make a right turn,
the vehicle are not supposed to swing left and turn;
instead, their should always cross the center line on the road that their are turning into
    ____________________
    -----------------------------
    _________________
|  |
|  |  (I hope this poor drawing might help you visualize what i am trying to say)
However, their instructor told the drivers to swing left before make a right turn, which is illegal

Anyway, the point i am trying to make is: instructors aren't always right,
no matter how much experience they have.  You might be taught that way, but that doesn't make it right
I trust a cop who works with law at the time better than an instructor
of coz, bottom line is that the cop could be wrong~
if thats the case, like what i said upthere: please pardon me (and good luck with your driving)

原帖由 dicksonboy 於 2007-2-16 15:02 發表
I quoted worlds from a HK police who had been working with the traffic law for years
If that wasn't good enough, then please pardon me


Let me tell you something about instrutors:
The transit next door (i am currently working for a transit and we share our dispatch office with another transit)
their drivers always turn illegally, and they were all taught that way by their instrutors:  
we drive on the right side, whenever the bus or a long vehicle make a right turn,
the vehicle are not supposed to swing left and turn;
instead, their should always cross the center line on the road that their are turning into
    ____________________
    -----------------------------
    _________________
|  |
|  |  (I hope this poor drawing might help you visualize what i am trying to say)
However, their instructor told the drivers to swing left before make a right turn, which is illegal

Anyway, the point i am trying to make is: instructors aren't always right,
no matter how much experience they have.  You might be taught that way, but that doesn't make it right
I trust a cop who works with law at the time better than an instructor
of coz, bottom line is that the cop could be wrong~
if thats the case, like what i said upthere: please pardon me (and good luck with your driving)

小弟對閤下講既野有保留...真係要check下香港既例先可以prove到你講既野...
如果有板友有可以check到的話, 歡迎回文quote出...

我好記得係英國考筆試時有一條題目係這樣的:

如果你見到一部巴士打右/左燈, 而它又逐漸在行車線稍左/右的位置行駛,
你應該:

1. 留在後面, 保持適當的距離
2. 在巴士的左邊超越
3. 在巴士的右邊超越
4. 響號

小弟唔係話唔信乜, 但係呢度討論, 如果真係想得到一個conclusion, 有時真係要有一個
reliable source of reference. 再者, 香港警察都有前科的, 例如:
"只准停車不准等候, 違者會被檢控" 的那些有黃線的停車灣,
警察一樣一直係度檢控, 但原來連法律效力都沒有的....

假如真係有條咁有趣的例, 係法理上, 舉證都有嚴重困難, 唔知d警察又點執法呢?!

[ 本帖最後由 hkbw 於 2007-2-16 18:55 編輯 ]

原帖由 hkbw 於 2007-2-16 18:37 發表


如果你見到一部巴士打右/左燈, 而它又逐漸在行車線稍左/右的位置行駛,
你應該:

1. 留在後面, 保持適當的距離
2. 在巴士的左邊超越
3. 在巴士的右邊超越
4. 響號

Please pardon me again if I confused you in the last post,
I am saying how should the bus driver make their turn, not the other drivers
In that case, their instructor teach them differently from what the drivers' manual says (which is illegal)
thats why I said even your instructor told you to do so, it could be wrong

P.S.: I don't know what's the correct answer for that exam question in the place that you can use only 1 hand to drive
But for myself, I would do #1.  This is what people say about defensive driving:
you can't stop others from making mistakes,
but you should try to keep yourself out from troubles
I am pretty sure buses are not supposed to swing wide before they turn, but you know what?
there are drivers do that (like the drivers at the transit next door!)
yea! their are wrong, so what? are you gonna pass them and hit them?
It's like you have a green light, and you see a kid just dart out from the sidewalk
what you gonna do? stop on a green light? or run the kid over because you have the green light?
By the way, i strongly recommend you to go ahead take a look of the drivers' manual for buses