香港大學U HALL最新消息

Quote:
break  在 2005-9-3 09:23 發表:
「親手繪畫」
是否不用尺子畫直線那種耶?~  

唔一定0既, 親手繪畫亦可以用尺子畫直線,
難道閣下在小學時已用Auto CAD 做數學題???

I believe those drawings are measured record plans. We never use free hand sketch for record drawings.


  Quote:
break  在 2005-9-3 09:23 發表:
與老娘同校的建築系學生話,
有教授叫他們不用其他工具來協助畫圖則耶~  



可能你未讀過建築,
果d 叫Free hand sketch / Free hand drawing
如果0岩Scale 的話一般可以接受用作presentation .
邊個話畫圖一定要用工具咖???

Please note that pens / pencils... are also tools. Please don't pick your finger.

2004年全年建築大獎的拔萃男書院的Design ,
都係由Free hand drawing 演變出來,

Computer aided drawing is a tool for producing a drawing, just like a pen / pencil / razor pointer...

Draughtsmanship of architecture graduates these years are deteriorating, as they are more asked to use CAD drawings to present their ideas. Our clients think that CAD drawings look better than hand drafts. But we practicioners think that both techniques can be equally good.

有教授叫他們不用其他工具來協助畫圖,
係因為係Concept Development 的階段時,
咁快有CAD 圖, 會令學生不想去大膽優化設計,
局限學生思考 , 而一個DESIGN 通常一般要到final stage
Freeze 左個design, 准presentation 前才用Auto CAD 畫出.

I agree with you to a certain extent. We usually do a conceptual design by hand. Then we convert the idea to CAD. But that may not be the final stage. Since CAD drawings can give us more idea of space available for different accommodations. A good designer not only focuses on design concepts and aesthetics, but he also needs to handle limitations like site constraints, area and statutory requirements.

建築學角度去看,Auto CAD 並非最重要的,
但較重要的就是Process, Concept ,Time management ,Critical Thinking .

Well, construction communication is very important in architectural design. No matter how good your concepts are, you cannot get your client's approval if you present it not nicely enough.

[ Last edited by abh on 2005-9-4 at 19:48 ]

[ref=360559]break[/ref]  在 2005-9-4 19:39 發表:

是呢,高人哥你引用的相片沒有打上"this is sg's picture, no copying pls",
是否代表大家今次可以copy?kindly please to reply me as soon as possible for our kind perusal and futher action.

唔明你做乜喎,
乜野叫futher action ?
你係咪指further action 呀 ?

[ref=360567]abh[/ref]  在 2005-9-4 19:44 發表:

Quote:
break  在 2005-9-3 09:23 發表:
Quote:
break  在 2005-9-3 09:23 發表:
「親手繪畫」
是否不用尺子畫直線那種耶?~  

唔一定0既, 親手繪畫亦可以用尺子畫直線,
難道閣下在小學時已用Auto CAD 做數學題???

I believe those drawings are measured record plans. We never use free hand sketch for record drawings.


  Quote:
break  在 2005-9-3 09:23 發表:
與老娘同校的建築系學生話,
有教授叫他們不用其他工具來協助畫圖則耶~  



可能你未讀過建築,
果d 叫Free hand sketch / Free hand drawing
如果0岩Scale 的話一般可以接受用作presentation .
邊個話畫圖一定要用工具咖???

Please note that pens / pencils... are also tools. Please don't pick your finger.

2004年全年建築大獎的拔萃男書院的Design ,
都係由Free hand drawing 演變出來,

Computer aided drawing is a tool for producing a drawing, just like a pen / pencil / razor pointer...

Draughtsmanship of architecture graduates these years are deteriorating, as they are more asked to use CAD drawings to present their ideas. Our clients think that CAD drawings look better than hand drafts. But we practicioners think that both techniques can be equally good.

有教授叫他們不用其他工具來協助畫圖,
係因為係Concept Development 的階段時,
咁快有CAD 圖, 會令學生不想去大膽優化設計,
局限學生思考 , 而一個DESIGN 通常一般要到final stage
Freeze 左個design, 准presentation 前才用Auto CAD 畫出.

I agree with you to a certain extent. We usually do a conceptual design by hand. Then we convert the idea to CAD. But that may not be the final stage. Since CAD drawings can give us more idea of space available for different accommodations. A good designer not only focuses on design concepts and aesthetics, but he also needs to handle limitations like site constraints, area and statutory requirements.

建築學角度去看,Auto CAD 並非最重要的,
但較重要的就是Process, Concept ,Time management ,Critical Thinking .

Well, construction communication is very important in architectural design. No matter how good your concepts are, you cannot get your client's approval if you present it not nicely enough.

在學同工作都有好大分別0既 !

講黎講去,吹黎吹去,都冇人貼平面圖,
等我用AUTOCAD畫再貼上黎先:

[ref=362534]break[/ref]  在 2005-9-6 11:17 PM 發表:



又是那些autocad吧~
你看,總是灰灰黑黑沒有氣息的,遮遮掩掩不如唔好貼啦~

呀break板友，
你睇咩野平面圖都係灰灰黑黑ga la!
你想有氣息既，就自己走去現場睇，唔好叫人貼.............
#:-/

[ref=363116]break[/ref]  在 2005-9-7 07:25 PM 發表:



老娘中文就話係教師級水平,
英文的確是麻麻耶~
題外話,老娘見過有支標(標書),都是錯字百出的,令人婉惜~是呀~

咁你又貼ｄ英文出來?
真係令人費解..............#:-[

[ref=362534]break[/ref]  在 2005-9-6 11:17 PM 發表:



又是那些autocad吧~
你看,總是灰灰黑黑沒有氣息的,遮遮掩掩不如唔好貼啦~

That was the colour scheme he chose. It doesn't mean that we cannot produce more colourful drawings.

Look at the colourful plans and perspectives in brochures. They can also be generated by computer aided design.

AutoCAD is a programme for computer aided drawing. There are many others and they are not only used in architecture.

The black background usually gives the user a more comfortable view when he do the drafting work. We can switch it to white background, but it is less comfortable and the contrast would not be that high.

Below shows a scheme design I made years ago.